What Is the Difference Between a Birth Defect and a Birth Injury
When your child is born with a health condition, you want answers. That’s completely natural. And pretty quickly, one question tends to lead to another: did someone make a mistake? Before you can even begin to figure that out, you need to understand a distinction that doesn’t always get explained clearly. A birth defect and a birth injury aren’t the same thing, and in Indiana, that difference can shape your entire legal situation.
Understanding Birth Defects
A birth defect is a structural or functional abnormality that develops during pregnancy itself. These conditions usually come from genetic factors, chromosomal irregularities, or environmental exposures that affect fetal development before labor ever begins. They’re not caused by what happens in the delivery room. Common examples include:
- Down syndrome
- Spina bifida
- Congenital heart defects
- Cleft palate
- Phenylketonuria (PKU)
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, birth defects affect approximately 1 in 33 babies born in the United States each year. Most of these conditions aren’t connected to medical negligence. They develop before delivery, often well before a family ever steps inside a hospital.
Understanding Birth Injuries
Birth injuries are different. A birth injury is physical harm that happens to a child during labor, delivery, or in the immediate period after birth. Something went wrong. That something can take many forms: improper use of forceps or vacuum tools, a failure to recognize or respond to fetal distress, a delayed decision to perform a cesarean section, or excessive force applied during delivery. Common birth injuries include:
- Brachial plexus injuries, such as Erb’s palsy
- Brain damage from oxygen deprivation (hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy)
- Cerebral palsy caused by delivery complications
- Fractured clavicle
- Facial nerve damage
These injuries are often preventable. That’s the part families need to hear. If a medical provider didn’t meet the accepted standard of care and a child was harmed as a result, there may be a legal claim worth pursuing.
Why the Distinction Matters Under Indiana Law
Indiana medical malpractice law gives injured patients and their families the right to seek compensation when a healthcare provider’s failure directly causes harm. That standard applies to birth injury cases. It generally doesn’t apply to birth defects that arise from genetics or prenatal development.
Here’s where it gets complicated. Some conditions, like cerebral palsy, can result from either a developmental issue or a mistake made in the delivery room. That overlap makes these cases genuinely difficult to evaluate without someone who knows what to look for. A Lafayette birth injury lawyer can review medical records in detail, identify where care may have fallen short, and help a family understand whether what happened was preventable.
Getting Answers After a Difficult Diagnosis
A life-changing diagnosis for your child is already a lot to carry. Trying to figure out whether legal action makes sense shouldn’t make it heavier. Start with what matters most: understanding what actually happened. Did the condition develop before birth? Or did something go wrong during delivery?
Hall-Justice Law Firm LLC works with Indiana families who are trying to make sense of their situation and whether they have a valid claim. If you believe your child was harmed during birth because of a medical mistake, reaching out to a Lafayette birth injury lawyer is a reasonable and important next step. You deserve real answers, not uncertainty, and the right legal guidance can help you get them.
EXCELLENT Based on 144 reviews Posted on BROOKE EGELHOFFTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Justice was very informative & kind & went above & beyond for me in every way she could . I highly recommend this attorney!!!!Posted on Brendan WhisenantTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Had an initial consult with the paralegal this morning. She was so polite, and very helpful. Listened, took my info and made the process very easy, in an area where I have a tough time finding attorney's. Thank YouPosted on CHARLIE CIEAZATrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mrs Hall did a great job in helping me get the best outcome for my case. I highly recommend her services.Posted on Bryant BryanTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I was fortunate to receive help from Susannah and her team. Susannah is a highly knowledgeable expert in her field. Although my requests was relatively straightforward for such an experienced professional, Susannah and her team provided me with outstanding support and answered all of my questions. I recommend discussing your specific situation with Susannah—even if it feels stressful—because she is excellent at analyzing circumstances and presenting clear options and potential actions. I have no doubt that Susannah and her team have the expertise to provide the best insight and guidance in their field.Posted on Jared MarcinkowskiTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Process went smoothlyPosted on Luke BeelerTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Susannah Hall-Justice is an amazing attorney! She was on top of things every step of the way and I am very thankful for her!Posted on Mrs. BenjaminTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I am currently a client of hers. I do get nervous going to court or just simply meeting with her as my lawyer because I never had to be in a situation that required me to need a lawyer! I feel safe with Ms. Hall-Justice because you can just tell she has your best interest! She listens, observes and make sure you are heard! I am praying to God I don’t have to look like what I’m going through because it’s stressful and I just want to go back to my regular life with my children!Posted on Markham CoatsTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. This attorney is definitely a credit to her craft! She is very personable and never talks down to a client. She makes a person feel like he/she is actually part of what's going on. She negotiated with the prosecutor and i was offered EVERYTHING that I had hoped for and even more! I would definitely hire her again and i highly recommend that you hire her and trust her in what is often a very vulnerable and confusing time.Posted on Joseph MorledgeTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. When we needed a Lafayette attorney to represent us for various charges, Susannah was all we could have hoped for. She had several charges dropped immediately and the remaining minor charges diverted for good behavior. After two months of good behavior, all charges were dismissed. Susannah and her assistant Erica were responsive, supportive and above all very effective. All at very reasonable rates. I have worked as a criminal defense lawyer in the past and I was very impressed.Posted on Devon JonesTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Impressive and refreshing. I called Susannah’s office first thing in the morning to inquire about a minor legal service and left my contact information with her assistant. Susannah personally called me back only a short while later despite how busy she undoubtedly is. It turned out that the legal opinion I required had to be from a practicing attorney in a different state so we didn’t go forward. Still, the fact that she personally returned my call, and was genuinely pleasant and attentive, substantiates her very positive and personal reviews. Not to stray into the negative but what a breath of fresh air compared to most of the attorneys with whom I’ve spoken in this area - routinely terse, rude and bumptious. This (Hall-Justice) is the law office I will call first for any future legal needs. Thank you.