Susannah Hall-Justice

For more than 25 years, Susannah Hall-Justice has been a strong voice for people across Indiana who need help after a serious injury or when facing criminal charges. She understands that these situations can completely turn your life upside down, which is why she takes the time to listen, explain your options clearly, and fight for the best possible outcome.

With licenses in both Indiana and Illinois, she offers clients a broad scope of representation and the experience needed to handle even the toughest cases.

Susannah’s path to the courtroom started on a farm outside Lafayette, where she learned the value of hard work and perseverance. After earning her undergraduate degree in American History from Harvard University, she went on to Indiana University Maurer School of Law, serving as a managing editor of a law journal before graduating in 1997. Since then, she has dedicated her career to helping clients secure justice in personal injury, wrongful death, and criminal defense matters. Her track record and commitment to clients are reflected in her excellent 4.8-star client reviews and a perfect 10.0 Avvo rating.

Clients who work with Susannah benefit not only from her legal knowledge but also from her leadership within the legal community. She has served as president of both the Carroll County and Tippecanoe County Bar Associations and currently sits on the Board of Governors of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association. She is also an active member of several professional organizations, including the Indiana State Bar Association, the Cass County Bar Association, and the National College for DUI Defense, Inc. These roles keep her connected with other leading attorneys and ensure her clients benefit from the most current legal strategies.

In addition to representing clients in the courtroom, Susannah is also a respected educator in the legal field. She has been invited to speak at Indiana Trial Lawyers Association seminars, where she has presented on topics such as wrongful death law, personal injury settlements, and representing children in injury cases. Her role as a lecturer demonstrates both her expertise and her willingness to share knowledge with other attorneys, further raising the standard of representation available to clients.

What truly sets Susannah apart is her personal approach to each case. She doesn’t believe in one-size-fits-all solutions, because she knows that every client’s story is different. Whether you’ve lost a loved one in a wrongful death case, suffered a serious injury, or are defending your reputation in a criminal matter, she works directly with you from start to finish. Clients appreciate her honesty, accessibility, and dedication to keeping them informed every step of the way.

Outside of her practice, Susannah remains deeply involved in her community. She has served on boards such as the West Lafayette Redevelopment Commission, Duncan Hall, and the Tippecanoe County Historical Association.

When she’s not in the office or courtroom, she enjoys spending time with her family, traveling, staying active, and reading.

• Personal Injury & Wrongful Death
• Criminal Defense
• Expungement & Record Sealing
• DUI / OWI Defense

Indiana School of Law, Bloomington

• J.D., Law, 1994 – 1997

Harvard University

• A.B., American History, 1987 – 1991

• Indiana State Bar
• Supreme Court of Illinois

• Board of Governors, Indiana Trial Lawyers Association
• Former President, Tippecanoe County Bar Association
• Former President, Carroll County Bar Association
• Member, Indiana State Bar Association
• Member, Cass County Bar Association
• Member, National College for DUI Defense

• Presenter at Indiana Trial Lawyers Association seminars on topics including wrongful death, representing children in injury cases, subrogation, and personal injury settlements
• Lecturer on expungement, focus groups, and insurance/Medicaid/Medicare-related issues in injury cases

• Board Member, West Lafayette Redevelopment Commission
• Board Member, Duncan Hall
• Board Member, Tippecanoe County Historical Association